Kendall Charcoal: Our Updated 2025 Review
By: Alexis B.
If you want an example of a paint color that stands the test of time, Kendall Charcoal by Benjamin Moore is a great one. We first reviewed this hue back in 2021, and we’ve since determined that this rich gray isn’t going anywhere. Even with the design world going through countless trends the past four years, Kendall Charcoal is still here to shine no matter what’s “in.”
Here’s why Kendall Charcoal deserves a chance at making your exterior “pop.”
Kendall Charcoal at a Glance
Kendall Charcoal, known as HC-166 by Benjamin Moore, is a deep, earthy gray with a Light Reflectance Value of 14.61. That means it soaks up more light than it bounces back, giving it a moody appearance.
This shade has subtle warm undertones that keep it from falling flat, which is one of the major reasons it works so well in different settings. It comes in every finish from matte to semi-gloss, and can work just as well inside your home as it does outside. It’s bold without being overwhelming, and moody without feeling dreary, making this charcoal color a go-to for exteriors.
What’s Changed Since Our 2021 Review?
Back in 2021, we praised Kendall Charcoal for being versatile and sophisticated, and that’s still true. What’s different now is the current design trends.
In 2021, there was a strong obsession with bright whites and stark contrasts. In 2025, homeowners are leaning toward cozier, earthy palettes. Luckily, dark neutrals like Kendall Charcoal still fit right in, since they anchor these warmer tones without feeling dated.
We’ve also noticed more homeowners taking risks with deeper shades on their exteriors. What once felt like a statement choice has now become more mainstream. If you were nervous about going dark before, you’ll find more inspiration now than ever on Pinterest (and even in your own neighborhood!).
First Impressions of This Gray
One of the most fascinating parts about Kendall Charcoal is that it doesn’t look the same in every setting. In natural light, this color leans sophisticated. On an exterior with tons of sunshine, it’s a strong, grounded gray. On a shaded north-facing wall, however, it can look deeper and moodier. If you’re expecting consistency throughout the day, you might not get it with this one.
That said, when paired with the right accents, this color always finds its balance. It’s about matching it well, which is really the biggest rule about any color you choose.
Why Kendall Charcoal Works Well
Balanced Undertones
This color strikes a rare balance. It’s warm enough to not look like a cold slab of concrete, but cool enough to not feel muddy. It’s a reliable choice if you’re worried about undertones clashing with exterior finishes.
Pairing Power
One of the biggest perks of this shade is how well it plays with other colors. Paired with crisp white, it can give you a classic high-contrast look. With muted pastels, it gives a softer, moodier vibe. You can also lean into earthy accents like stone or copper to highlight its richness.
Timeless Neutrality
While some colors seem trendier than others, Kendall Charcoal is more of a quiet classic. It doesn’t lean too modern or traditional, so it can live comfortably in a range of design styles. Whether you’ve got a classic Craftsman or a sleek new build, this color won’t feel out of place.
Drawbacks and Cautions for Kendall Charcoal
No color is perfect, of course. Here are some reasons to reconsider this shade if you’re on the fence.
Can Feel Heavy
If your home is in a particularly shady area, it may come across too dark for your liking. Opting to use it on accents like trim or doors may be a better choice than using it for a base color in these situations.
Sensitive Undertones
Though this shade has undertones that work well with many other colors, it can also cause it to look different. Next to warm wood tones, this grey might look crisp. Near cool metals, it might feel more brown. If you’re not careful with your accent colors, this shade could throw off your design plan.
Maintenance Factors
Darker colors show dust, fingerprints, and imperfections more easily than lighter ones, especially in dusty climates. Consider the region your home is in before taking the plunge on a darker shade like this.
Surface Prep Matters
If you skip priming or skimp on sanding, this color will tell on you. Uneven application shows more on darker colors like this, so investing time in prep is essential to get the results you want.
Pro Tips for Applying Kendall Charcoal
Dark paint colors always require a little more planning, and Kendall Charcoal is no exception. Always test with swatches before taking the full plunge. Smaller chips can be misleading, especially with a color this deep. Using a bigger swatch can show you how it will look at different times of day.
Make sure you test this shade against your intended trim and accent shades, too. A pure white trip may brighten it, while a warmer off-white may make it look more subdued.
Finally, don’t forget about texture. This color looks excellent when paired with natural wood, stone, or metal accents. This is a great way to create depth and keep this color from feeling flat.
Final Thoughts: Is Kendall Charcoal Still Worth It in 2025?
Yes! If you’re looking for a deep, versatile gray that still feels current, Kendall Charcoal is an excellent choice. It’s bold, sophisticated, and adaptable to a variety of styles without washing them out. If you’re still unsure, try it as an accent color first to see if you’re ready to embrace the dark side.
Interested in seeing how your home would look with this color? Our expert designers have you covered. Start your virtual exterior design today to see how Kendall Charcoal can make your home the envy of the neighborhood.
Subscribe for more content like this!