8 Rustic Paint Colors for Home Exteriors

If you love the feeling of mountain homes and cabins and you’re thinking of updating your exterior, you may be in the market for a fresh design scheme featuring rustic paint colors. When our designers partner with homeowners to help them see the potential in a home with a rustic design, paint plays an important role. Rustic homes often feature wood accents and may also have stone or brick cladding. Ensuring that all of the hues and undertones work together for a cohesive, intentional design is a big part of what we do. Read on for some of our experts’ favorite rustic paint colors for home exteriors.

Struggling to pick the paint color that’s perfect for your home and your style? Overwhelmed by all of the decisions that go into updating your curb appeal? OUR TEAM OF EXPERT EXTERIOR DESIGNERS IS READY TO HELP YOU VISUALIZE YOUR HOME’S POTENTIAL. LEARN MORE ABOUT OUR VIRTUAL DESIGN SERVICES


The front of a rustic style home rendered in Deep Creek and Revere Pewter
The back of a rustic style home rendered in Deep Creek and Revere Pewter

#1 // Deep Creek + Revere Pewter

This low-slung Arizona home is in a beautiful natural setting, and the owner was looking for an update that gave their curb appeal more charm. Our designers suggested a two-tone exterior in warm, earthy neutrals. Benjamin Moore’s Deep Creek on the shingle siding and Revere Pewter on the brick give the façade depth. These rustic paint colors also work well with the plentiful wood design elements, which emphasize a nature-inspired aesthetic.


A Tudor-style home with Jet Black siding

#2 // Jet Black

Our designers brought some rustic flair to this Tudor-style home with a few simple touches. We rendered the trim and siding in Benjamin Moore’s Jet Black for contrast that complements the natural red brick. The pergola over the front patio and garage doors bring the look home (pun intended).


Rustic style home with siding in Anonymous and stone and wood cladding accents
Rustic style home entry with siding in Anonymous and stone and wood cladding accents

#3 // Anonymous

Sherwin Williams’ Anonymous was the perfect rustic paint color choice for this Idaho home. Another complex earthy neutral, it works beautifully with the stone cladding, wood cladding and accents, and dark metal roof. Tricorn Black provides contrast on the eaves and soffit.


Modern rustic home with James Hardie siding in Shou Sugi Ban

#4 // Shou Sugi Ban

One of James Hardie’s baked-in siding colors, and part of their Dream Collection, Shou Sugi Ban is a brick&batten favorite for modern rustic home exteriors. On the Utah home above, Shou Sugi Ban is featured on a combination of vertical and shingle siding. It acts as a rich, deep back layer against the warm gray stone cladding.


Aegean Olive and Black Beauty on a rustic home

#5 // Aegean Olive

Benjamin Moore’s Aegean Olive is our go-to dark olive green exterior paint color. Our designers used it to gorgeous effect on the modern rustic North Carolina home above. Black Beauty on accents and a black shingle roof give the curb appeal a dark, moody vibe. Next, wood columns, trusses, and garage doors provide warmth. Finally, stone cladding on the columns, chimney, and lower half of the garage portion of the home offers a bright visual layer against the dark backdrop.

WE ALWAYS RECOMMEND SAMPLING AND TESTING PAINT COLORS BEFORE COMMITTING. FACTORS SUCH AS NATURAL LIGHTING, UNDERTONES, AND YOUR PROPERTY’S FIXED ELEMENTS WILL HAVE A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON HOW A COLOR WILL APPEAR ON YOUR EXTERIOR. OUR FRIENDS AT SAMPLIZE OFFER EXTRA-LARGE 9 X 14.75 INCH PEEL-AND-STICK PAINT SAMPLES OF THE COLORS WE LOVE FOR EXTERIORS. ORDER YOUR ‘REAL PAINT, NO MESS’ SAMPLES FROM SAMPLIZE HERE.

New construction home featuring rustic paint colors Weathered Windmills from Magnolia and Urbane Bronze

#6 // Weathered Windmill

The new construction home above features a unique combination of rustic paint colors and cladding options. Magnolia’s Weathered Windmills on the siding and Sherwin Williams’ Urbane Bronze on the trim and fascia are gorgeous with the aged cedar shingle siding and colorful stone skirting.


Rustic lake cabin in Urbane Bronze

#7 // Urbane Bronze

Urbane Bronze isn’t only an accent color. It’s also an excellent overall rustic paint color choice, as demonstrated by its use on the Montana lake cabin above. Here, it’s paired with Iron Ore on the trim, the client’s existing metal roof color, and wood and stone design elements.


Ashwood Moss on a rustic Craftsman-style home exterior
Ashwood Moss on a rustic Craftsman-style home exterior, side view

#8 // Ashwood Moss

Our designers brought a rustic feel to this Craftsman-style home with paint color and design element recommendations. Benjamin Moore’s Ashwood Moss on the shake siding is lovely and warm alongside the stone cladding. This graphite-green is a beautiful and versatile neutral that we love in all sorts of executions. Here, we used Baby Fawn to accentuate the eaves and trim and Black Beauty to modernize the windows.


Dark exterior on modern rustic lake home in upstate New York

Rustic paint colors are just the beginning

As you can see from the designs featured in this post, paint colors are only one part of a stunning rustic exterior design. Paint is an important part of what we do. But everything from decking material to exterior lighting to garage doors has to come together if you’re going to feel happy with your curb appeal update. And that’s what the experts at brick&batten are here to help you with.

Our team of exterior designers use a photo (or blueprint) of your home and the inspiration you provide to create a virtual rendering of your new design. Plus, we provide you with a resource list to help you execute the look. Get started on making your exterior dreams a reality today!

Author