Smart Homeowner Secrets for Finding and Managing a Reliable Contractor

A reliable contractor can be the single factor to preventing a catastrophe of a home renovation project. Honest and organized contractors ensure high quality work, meet deadlines, and stick to the budget. With so many options though, how do you separate the dependable experts from the unreliable ones? The answer is research, communication, and a lot of patience.

Before hiring anyone, take time to investigate. The prep work may be annoying at first, but can save you money, stress, and time in the long run. Below, we share our tips for finding a reliable contractor.

Want to refresh your home’s. exterior paint color? Our paint visualizer package is perfect for you. And if you do need help with other aspects of your exterior, we’ve got you covered there too. Learn all about our virtual exterior design services.

Our designers only use and recommend products that we know, love, or would use on our own properties. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission, at no cost to you. 


Virtual rendering of a Tudor style home with greige trim and an arched front door.

Research, research, research

Check reviews and testimonials

Start with online reviews. Websites like Google, Houzz, and even the Better Business Bureau provide insight and firsthand experience with the contractor from previous clients. Look for any patterns throughout the reviews such as consistent praise about their quality of work, their professionalism, and timeliness. If you notice patterns of complaints, consider it a red flag and move on.

Ask for referrals

Word of mouth recommendations are one of the best ways to find a reliable contractor. Ask around to friends, family, and neighbors about their experiences. Better yet, if you’re looking for a subcontractor, reach out to well-established builders you like and ask if they know of any they can recommend. If you’re looking for a builder, a good place to start is their social media. Websites are great to learn more about a company and to view portfolios, but they aren’t updated often. Social media, on the other hand, is normally a good representation of current work and comments can tell you a lot about their reputation and how they’re perceived.

Verify licensing and insurance

A professional contractor will hold the proper licenses and insurance to operate as a business. Check your state and local requirements, then confirm that the contractor meets them. Proper credentials protect you from liability and mean the contractor likely follows building codes.

Review their portfolio

An experienced contractor should have an up to date portfolio located on a website. This will show their previous work where you can view their quality, style, and consistency. Sometimes, builders will have open houses where the public can view their work. That would be a great opportunity to see in person if they’re a good fit for your project.

Digital rendering of a Mediterranean house with brown garage doors and a brown roof on a post about how to find a reliable contractor.

Time to narrow down the choices

Conduct interviews

Once you’ve compiled a list of contractors you’d like to reach out to, conduct thorough interviews. During this time you’ll have the chance to ask them all the necessary questions, listen to how they communicate, and determine if they could be easy to work with. A simple conversation can provide a lot of insight for how it could be when working with them.

To elaborate, a reliable contractor responds promptly and doesn’t ghost you. They explain things clearly and are willing to answer questions, even the mundane ones. If they dodge questions or dismiss your concerns, consider it another red flag. Good communication is a must for a home renovation to run smoothly.

Ask the right questions

When interviewing contractors, there are a whole host of questions that should be your baseline, before getting into specifics. These questions include asking about their processes, their timeline, and how they’ll communicate progress and issues to you. Luckily, we’ve done the hard work for you by putting together a list of questions to ask your contractor to see if they’re a good fit.

 Request a detailed estimate

A contractor should always be willing to provide a detailed estimate for the project before any work has begun. It should break down labor, materials, and any additional costs. Avoid contractor whose pricing is vague or only works off verbal agreements. Everything should be documented and easy to understand. Clear documentation helps prevent miscommunication and disputes later.

WE ALWAYS RECOMMEND SAMPLING AND TESTING PAINT COLORS BEFORE COMMITTING. FACTORS SUCH AS NATURAL LIGHTING, UNDERTONES, AND YOUR PROPERTY’S FIXED ELEMENTS WILL HAVE A SIGNIFICANT IMPACT ON HOW A COLOR WILL APPEAR ON YOUR EXTERIOR. OUR FRIENDS AT SAMPLIZE OFFER EXTRA-LARGE 9 X 14.75 INCH PEEL-AND-STICK PAINT SAMPLES OF THE COLORS WE LOVE FOR EXTERIORS. ORDER YOUR ‘REAL PAINT, NO MESS’ SAMPLES FROM SAMPLIZE HERE.

Virtual rendering of a traditional home with black windows, a wood pergola, and a wood garage door.

Manage the project with confidence

Getting the right contractor for the job is just the first step. Now, there needs to be management of the project to keep things on track and stress free. Your communication is just as important. Make sure to define your goals, budget, and preferred timeline upfront. Make sure all of this is in writing as well, including any design details. This eliminates confusion and keeps everyone accountable for their part of the collaboration.

Schedule consistent updates

Frequent progress updates help catch issues before they spiral into bigger problems. They can also act as reassurance for you to ease stress. Weekly progress reviews can also address concerns and keep the project on schedule.

Document everything

Keep a record of all contracts, proposals, payments, change orders, designs or renderings, and messages between you and the contractor. Written or signed agreements protect both of you if there are unexpected costs, broken or stolen items, or a misunderstanding.

Stay flexible

In home renovation or building, it’s inevitable that delays happen. You may need to make small shifts, but don’t let minor setbacks turn into major setbacks. If something feels off, address it immediately. For example, if painting has started and the trim color is white, but just doesn’t quite seem like the white you chose – say something. For peace of mind, check the label of the paint to be sure and go from there. You’ll thank yourself in the end, even if that white paint was right.

Also, a reliable contractor will work with you to find a solution. If they patient and willing to listen to your concerns, you’ve likely found a good one.


Digital rendering of a midcentury modern home with white columns, white windows, and simple landscaping.

Watch out for common pitfalls

Even the best contractor can make mistakes. In order to protect yourself even further, avoid these common pitfalls.

Don’t pay everything up front. Reputable contractors won’t demand the full amount before starting. A normal and reasonable deposit ranges between 10-30% of the total cost quoted. Installments throughout the project are a smart way to reenforce accountability.

If a contractor’s proposal or estimate is too good to be true, err on the side of caution. Low bids oftentimes means cut corners, cheap materials, or even hidden costs. Always choose a contractor with fair and transparent pricing!

Trust your instincts. Listen to your gut. Going into a renovation project shouldn’t be stressful. You should feel confident and, of course, excited! If communication starts to decline or if promises sound disingenuous, reconsider your choice.


Blog post about how to find a reliable contractor with accompanying photo of a Mediterranean style home.

Feeling confident yet?

The task of finding a reliable contractor takes effort, but the results are worth it! Not only will you have a beautiful and high quality project, but it will be enjoyable getting to that point. Doing your homework and research, setting clear expectations, and staying involved set you up for a great renovation without the headaches and stress.

Our Pro Network is a fantastic resource to find contractors in your area. As for your design? All we need are your answers to our short questionnaire for our designers to get started on it! We’ll even provide a shoppable resource list so getting started is as easy as clicking a few links. Get started here.

Author

Schedule a Complimentary Call